Alabaster vs White Dove vs Chantilly Lace: Which White to Pick

The same kitchen with white shaker cabinets twice: a soft warm white Alabaster wall on the left and a deep navy Hale Navy wall on the right

Alabaster (SW 7008) is the warmest of the three, a soft creamy white. White Dove (OC-17) sits in the middle: a little lighter and a little less yellow. Chantilly Lace (OC-65) is the cleanest and brightest, close to a neutral white. Pick Alabaster for cozy, north-facing rooms, White Dove for walls and trim through a whole house, and Chantilly Lace for crisp trim, ceilings and modern rooms.

Side by side on a chip, these three look almost the same, but on a wall they separate. Below are the numbers behind that, and where each one works. Hex values come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro (for White Dove from its matching entry there). Manufacturer LRV comes from the Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore color pages, linked in the table. A screen only approximates a white, and whites shift more than any other color with light, so a large sample on the wall has the final say.

The three whites side by side

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (manufacturer) LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 #EDEAE0 82 82.2
Benjamin Moore White Dove OC-17 #EFEEE5 83.16 85.2
Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace OC-65 (also 2121-70) #F4F6F1 90.04 91.5

LRV (light reflectance value) tells you how much light a color reflects, from 0 for black to 100 for pure white. The manufacturer's LRV is measured; our calculated LRV comes from the hex value, which is why the two columns differ slightly. Chantilly Lace is sold as OC-65 in the Off-White Collection and as 2121-70 in Color Preview; both get you the same color.

What the numbers say:

  • Brightness: Chantilly Lace reflects noticeably more light (LRV 90) than White Dove (83) and Alabaster (82). Alabaster and White Dove are close in brightness.
  • Warmth: in the CIELAB color space we calculated from the hex values, the yellow component (b*) is 5.2 for Alabaster, 4.5 for White Dove and 2.2 for Chantilly Lace. The higher the number, the creamier the white looks.

How different are they really?

ΔE (CIEDE2000) measures how far apart two colors are. In Muro's color matching, under 1 counts as practically identical and 1 to 2 as very close.

Pair ΔE
Alabaster vs White Dove 1.24
White Dove vs Chantilly Lace 2.63
Alabaster vs Chantilly Lace 3.77

So Alabaster and White Dove are near neighbors. You will see the difference side by side, but either can stand in for the other in most rooms. Chantilly Lace is clearly the odd one out. Painted next to Alabaster on trim, it makes Alabaster look creamier, and Alabaster makes it look whiter.

Alabaster (SW 7008): the warm one

Alabaster has the most yellow in it of the three and the lowest LRV. In a north-facing room, where daylight is cool and bluish, that warmth keeps the walls from going gray. With wood floors, beige stone and warm lighting it looks soft and cozy. In a hot, sunny south- or west-facing room it can lean more cream than white, so test it in afternoon sun.

If your store does not carry Sherwin-Williams, these are near twins:

Brand Color Code Hex ΔE to Alabaster
Benjamin Moore Dune White 968 #ECEAE0 0.50
Behr Salt Crystal QE-25 #EFEBE0 0.61

It suits living rooms and bedrooms with warm wood, kitchens with cream or wood cabinets, and a whole house done in a warm palette. For cabinets specifically, see best paint colors for kitchen cabinets.

White Dove (OC-17): the middle ground

White Dove is a touch lighter and less yellow than Alabaster. Benjamin Moore describes it as "clean and classic." It stays soft without reading as cream, which is why it works on walls, trim and cabinets at the same time: one white, everywhere, with different sheens. It is a safe choice when rooms face different directions and you do not want to pick a white per room. Open floor plans are the obvious case.

Near twins in other brands:

Brand Color Code Hex ΔE to White Dove
Behr Snowy Pine PPU10-13 #F0EEE5 0.49
Valspar Paramount White 7006-22 #ECECE4 0.73

Chantilly Lace (OC-65): the clean, bright one

Chantilly Lace has the highest LRV and the least yellow. Next to it, most other whites look creamy. That makes it the go-to white for crisp trim, doors and ceilings, and for modern rooms with gray, black or blue. The catch: in a dim north-facing room, a clean white with little warmth can look flat or slightly gray, and next to warm beige walls it can make them look more yellow.

Near twins in other brands:

Brand Color Code Hex ΔE to Chantilly Lace
Behr Snow Fall W-F-600 #F6F8F3 0.41
Sherwin-Williams High Reflective White SW 7757 #F7F7F1 1.01

It also does well next to cool grays and blues, in modern kitchens, in bright south-facing rooms and on gallery-style walls for art. For south-facing rooms in particular, see best paint colors for south-facing rooms.

Which one with which wall color?

When one of the three goes on trim, match its lean to the wall. Our trim paint guide covers this in more detail.

Wall color Code Hex Trim white that fits
Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 #D1CBC1 Alabaster or White Dove
Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter HC-172 #CBC6B8 White Dove
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154 #434B56 Chantilly Lace or White Dove
Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze SW 7048 #54504A Alabaster

Benjamin Moore itself lists Revere Pewter (HC-172) among the shades related to White Dove on its color page.

What to avoid

Don't choose from a 2-inch chip. These three differ by small amounts that only show on a big surface, so paint samples at least the size of a sheet of paper. And don't test them on an old white wall, because next to an existing white any of these can look dirty or blue. Put the sample on white poster board, or compare all three at once.

Alabaster walls with Chantilly Lace trim can work on purpose, but if you wanted one quiet white, the contrast will make Alabaster look yellow. Last, look at them at more than one time of day. Warm whites look warmest in evening lamp light, and clean whites look coolest on cloudy mornings.

How to check a white before you buy

  1. Paint large samples of two or three whites side by side, on the wall that gets the most light and on the darkest wall.
  2. Look in the morning, at noon and in the evening, with your own bulbs on.
  3. Hold them against your trim, cabinets and floor, since a white always sits next to something.

To avoid ending up with a stack of sample pots, you can narrow it down in Muro first. You take a photo of your room, pick a real paint by name or code, for example Alabaster (SW 7008) or Chantilly Lace, and see it on your own walls. In the iPhone app you can view the room by day, at sunset and at night, with lamps on or off, which is when whites change the most. You can also start in your browser at app.usemuro.com. For more whites with codes and LRV, see our list of the best white paint colors, and if you are unsure what "warm" and "cool" mean for a white, white paint undertones explained.

FAQ

Is Alabaster warmer than White Dove?

Yes. Alabaster (SW 7008) has a slightly higher yellow component and a slightly lower LRV (82 vs 83.16), so it reads creamier. The two are close, at ΔE 1.24.

Is Chantilly Lace too white or too stark?

It is the brightest and cleanest of the three (LRV 90.04), but it is not a pure, blue-white. In bright rooms and on trim it looks crisp; in a dim north-facing room it can look flat, where Alabaster (SW 7008) is the safer choice.

Which is better for kitchen cabinets: White Dove or Alabaster?

Both work. White Dove (OC-17) is a little less yellow and is easy to repeat on walls and trim. Alabaster (SW 7008) is cozier next to wood counters or warm stone.

Is White Dove good for trim?

Yes, especially when the walls are warm grays or greige such as Agreeable Gray (SW 7029). Next to bright white tile or cool gray walls, Chantilly Lace (OC-65) looks crisper. Agreeable Gray is reviewed in the Agreeable Gray review.

What is the Sherwin-Williams equivalent of Chantilly Lace?

In Muro's color data, the closest Sherwin-Williams color is High Reflective White (SW 7757), ΔE 1.01. Behr Snow Fall (W-F-600) is even closer, at ΔE 0.41.

What is the Benjamin Moore equivalent of Alabaster?

Dune White (968), at ΔE 0.50: practically the same color.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles