Benjamin Moore vs Behr: Colors, Twins, What to Buy

The same bedroom twice: a soft greige wall in Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter on the left, a dark charcoal wall in Behr Cracked Pepper on the right

Benjamin Moore and Behr are close on muted colors: in our sample, 84% of muted Behr colors (grays, beiges, whites) had a Benjamin Moore twin within ΔE 2, which you'd only spot with chips side by side. On bright and dark colors a twin is less likely (58% vs 84%). They also differ on where you buy: Behr is sold at The Home Depot, Benjamin Moore at independent paint stores.

This post compares what we can check: where each brand is sold, published prices, and color data. Codes and hex values come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. A hex value is only an approximation on screen, so a sample on your wall has the final say. We didn't run our own coverage or durability tests, so we don't rank paint quality. For the other big matchup, see Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore.

Benjamin Moore vs Behr at a glance

Benjamin Moore Behr
Colors with values in Muro 3,884 4,491
Where you buy in the U.S. Locally owned retailers The Home Depot (exclusive in the retail channel in North America)
Price per gallon online On the brand's site On the retailer's site, not the brand's
Code format Numbers and collection prefixes (1495, HC-154, OC-20, AF-655) Letters and numbers by collection (PPU18-01, MQ3-32, HDC-MD-01)

Behr's owner, Masco, says in its 2025 annual report that Home Depot has Behr brand exclusivity in the retail channel in North America. No Home Depot nearby usually means no Behr on a shelf. Benjamin Moore goes the other way: no big-box chain, only independent dealers. The color counts are what Muro holds with a published value, so read them as rough sizes of the two fan decks.

How much does a gallon cost?

Benjamin Moore lists prices on its own site. These were the 1-gallon prices on November 16, 2026:

Benjamin Moore line Sheen checked Price per gallon
ben Interior Eggshell $60.99
Regal Select Interior Eggshell $84.99
Advance Interior/Exterior High Gloss $88.99
Aura Interior Eggshell $108.99

Each dealer sets its own final price, so your store may differ.

Behr doesn't sell on its own site, and the price is whatever The Home Depot charges that week. Its interior lines include Premium Plus, Marquee and Dynasty. We couldn't load current Home Depot prices for this post, so we don't quote a number. Before you compare, check the exact line and sheen on homedepot.com or in the store. Compare top line with top line (Aura against Dynasty, say), not one brand's best paint against the other's cheapest. For the whole job, see how much it costs to paint a room.

Colors: how often does a Behr color have a Benjamin Moore twin?

This is usually the real question: you found a color you like, but the other store is ten minutes closer.

Part of the older Behr colors in our database have uncertain color values, so in this post we use only the Behr code families PPU, MQ and HDC, whose values matched a second source in spot checks. That's 1,151 colors, a quarter of the Behr deck in Muro.

How we measured it. We drew a random sample of 200 of those Behr colors and found the closest Benjamin Moore color for each among all Benjamin Moore colors in Muro's data, measured with CIEDE2000 (ΔE 2000). Below 1, most people can't see a difference. Below 2, you'd notice it only with the chips side by side.

Closest Benjamin Moore twin Behr colors (200)
ΔE below 1 (practically identical) 47 (24%)
ΔE below 2 (very close) 142 (71%)
ΔE below 3.5 (close) 195 (98%)
Nothing within ΔE 6 0

How strong the color is matters most. Among muted colors (grays, beiges, whites, soft greens), 83 of 99 had a Benjamin Moore twin within ΔE 2, or 84%. Among stronger, more saturated colors, it was 59 of 101, or 58%. We count a color as muted when its HSV saturation is below 0.25; everything else counts as strong, and that includes dark navies and charcoals, not only bright colors. We didn't run the other direction, because limiting Behr to the checked codes would make its fan deck look smaller than it is.

It's a sample, not the full catalog, so read the numbers as a direction. For the picture across 34 brands, see our study of 51,362 paint colors.

Color Code Hex Closest twin in the other brand ΔE
Benjamin Moore Pale Oak OC-20 #DDD9CE Behr Ginger Sugar MQ3-18 0.63
Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter HC-172 #CBC6B8 Behr Coliseum Marble PPU8-16 1.01
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154 #434B56 Behr Starless Night PPU14-20 1.54
Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal HC-166 #676662 Behr Mined Coal PPU18-18 1.71
Benjamin Moore Silhouette AF-655 #57504C Behr Gardeners Soil MQ2-54 2.19
Behr Cameo White MQ3-32 #E9E6E1 Benjamin Moore Lacey Pearl 2108-70 0.55
Behr Silky White PPU7-12 #EEEBE3 Benjamin Moore Dune White 968 1.20
Behr Cracked Pepper PPU18-01 #4F5152 Benjamin Moore French Beret 1610 1.43

For Benjamin Moore colors, the Behr column lists the closest Behr color with a PPU, MQ or HDC code. Pale Oak and Cameo White switch brands with no visible change. Revere Pewter and Hale Navy are close enough that most rooms won't give it away, but put both samples up anyway. Silhouette, Benjamin Moore's 2026 color of the year, is the warning case: Gardeners Soil is clearly different side by side. If you're set on Revere Pewter, our Revere Pewter review goes deeper. More navies, including Hale Navy, are in best navy blue paint colors.

Same name, different color

Of the Behr colors with checked codes, 80 share a name with a Benjamin Moore color. We compared the 58 names that point to just one color in each brand. The median gap was ΔE 14.7, and not one pair came in under ΔE 2.

Name Benjamin Moore Behr
Verdigris 685, #55756C, deep blue-green PPU12-14, #B0B8B1, pale green-gray
Free Spirit 245, #978466, khaki brown MQ4-18, #B1DBC7, pale mint
Majestic Blue 2051-40, #629FA0, teal HDC-MD-01, #3E405E, dark indigo

"Free Spirit" alone could mean a brown wall or a mint one. Write down the brand and the code.

Which one should you buy?

  • You already have a color picked. Buy that brand if you can. If the other store is closer, look up the twin's ΔE first: below 1, switch without worrying; between 1 and 2, compare samples; above 2, treat it as a different color.
  • Your color is a gray, beige or off-white. In our sample, 84% of muted Behr colors had a Benjamin Moore twin within ΔE 2, so convenience and price can decide.
  • Your color is bright or saturated. Stay with the original brand if you can. A close twin is less likely here (58% vs 84% for muted colors), so compare samples before you switch.
  • A painter is doing the job. Ask which brand they buy and at what price. Pros often get account pricing that's lower than the shelf.

What to avoid

  • Ordering by name. Verdigris, Free Spirit and Majestic Blue above show how far apart two colors with the same name can be.
  • Asking the store to match another brand by eye. A computer match is a new formula in a different base. Ask for the closest color from their own fan deck, so you get a code you can reorder. More in our post on matching paint colors across manufacturers.
  • Comparing prices across lines or sheens. An entry line in flat and a top line in eggshell aren't the same product.

How to check a color before you buy

Get two samples, at least a foot square, and put them on two walls: one near the window, one in the darkest corner. Look in the morning, at midday and in the evening with lamps on.

To narrow the list before you buy samples, you can use Muro. Take a photo of your room, pick real paints from either brand by name or code, and see them on your own walls side by side, for example Revere Pewter next to Coliseum Marble. In the iPhone app you can switch the room between day, sunset and night. In your browser, start at app.usemuro.com. When the color is settled, the paint calculator tells you how much to buy.

FAQ

Is Benjamin Moore better than Behr?

Not across the board. Benjamin Moore sells through independent dealers and lists prices on its site; Behr is sold at The Home Depot. On color, muted shades usually have a close twin in the other brand. We didn't test coverage or durability, so compare the product data sheets of the two lines you're considering.

Can Home Depot match Benjamin Moore colors in Behr paint?

The store can mix a computer match, but it's a new formula. A safer route is a Behr color with its own code that's close to the original, for example Behr Starless Night (PPU14-20) for Hale Navy (HC-154), ΔE 1.54.

What is the Behr equivalent of Revere Pewter?

The closest in Muro is Behr Coliseum Marble (PPU8-16), ΔE 1.01 from Revere Pewter (HC-172). Close enough for most rooms, but compare the samples on your wall.

What is the Behr equivalent of Pale Oak?

Behr Ginger Sugar (MQ3-18), ΔE 0.63 from Pale Oak (OC-20). That's practically identical on paper.

What is the Benjamin Moore equivalent of Cracked Pepper?

Benjamin Moore French Beret (1610), ΔE 1.43 from Behr Cracked Pepper (PPU18-01). Very close, though side by side you may notice it.

Which brand has more colors?

In Muro, Behr: 4,491 colors with published values against 3,884 for Benjamin Moore. A bigger deck doesn't mean better twins, though: what matters is whether your color is muted or bright.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles