On a vinyl siding house, you mostly add color through the front door, the shutters and any wood trim, because the siding and the white vinyl trim stay. Black (Tricorn Black, SW 6258), navy (Hale Navy, HC-154), deep green (Tarrytown Green, HC-134) and a brick red (Caliente, AF-290) suit white, gray and tan siding. If you repaint the vinyl itself, never go darker than the original color, and with Benjamin Moore stay at LRV 55 or above unless the color is in the vinyl palette Benjamin Moore names for that paint.
Vinyl siding comes in a fixed factory color, and the windows, corners and J-channel are usually white or almond vinyl you won't touch. So you pick the few things that take paint well and make them work with what's on the walls. Codes, hex values and LRV come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. A hex value on a screen is only an approximation, and outdoor light shifts everything, so a sample next to the siding always has the final say.
First, look at what you can't change
Stand across the street on a bright day and note three things:
- The siding color. Plain white, light gray, tan or clay, or a soft blue or green. Each of these takes different accents.
- The trim and windows. Bright white vinyl trim calls for crisp accents like black and navy. Almond or beige trim is warmer and goes better with bronze, green and red.
- The roof. A black or charcoal roof makes black shutters look planned. A brown roof leans toward bronze or deep green.
Then sort the parts by material. A steel, fiberglass or wood front door can take any color, and so can wood porch posts and railings. Vinyl shutters are thin PVC like the siding, so the same heat rules apply.
What to avoid on a vinyl siding house
- Painting vinyl darker than it is now. All three big US paint brands say this. Sherwin-Williams writes that warping is likely when "vinyl siding was repainted with a darker color paint than the original color". Behr says to avoid a darker color on vinyl siding "or other thin exterior PVC material" unless the paint or siding maker says otherwise.
- Black vinyl shutters from a can. If the shutters came white or almond, painting them near-black falls under the same rule. Replacement shutters made in black are the safer way to get that look.
- Matching the door to the siding. A gray door on gray siding disappears. Go clearly darker or pick a real color.
- A cold, blue-white next to almond trim. It makes the trim look dirty.
Accents for white vinyl siding
White siding is the easiest base. It takes almost any deep color on the door and shutters, and black is the safe default. If you like that crisp look, white house with black trim goes further into it.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Tricorn Black | SW 6258 | #2F2F30 |
| Behr | Cracked Pepper | PPU18-01 | #4F5152 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Naval | SW 6244 | #2F3D4C |
| Benjamin Moore | Caliente | AF-290 | #8A2728 |
Cracked Pepper is a soft black that looks gentler than Tricorn Black on a small ranch. A red door like Caliente works best when the shutters stay black or navy.
Accents for gray vinyl siding
Gray siding is everywhere, and the risk is that the whole house turns into one flat tone. Pick an accent with clear depth or clear color. Navy and dark teal look natural against cool gray. On a warm, greige-leaning gray, try bronze or a deep green.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Hale Navy | HC-154 | #434B56 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Rainstorm | SW 6230 | #244653 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Iron Ore | SW 7069 | #434341 |
| Behr | Totally Black | HDC-MD-04 | #3E3F41 |
Accents for tan, beige and clay vinyl siding
Tan and clay siding usually comes with almond trim. Warm accents look best here: bronze, deep green and brick red. Black works too, but a brown-black is kinder to beige than a blue-black.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Urbane Bronze | SW 7048 | #54504A |
| Benjamin Moore | Tarrytown Green | HC-134 | #415752 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Fired Brick | SW 6335 | #83382A |
| Sherwin-Williams | Pewter Green | SW 6208 | #5E6259 |
If you're adding new wood trim, such as porch posts or a gable board, don't use a stark white next to almond vinyl. A creamy white like Alabaster (SW 7008, #EDEAE0) or Behr Ivory Palace (PPU10-14, #EEE9DD) sits much closer. The trim paint color guide covers sheen and the rest of the trim question.
Can you paint the vinyl siding itself?
Yes, as long as the siding is sound, properly hung and you follow the paint maker's color rules. These are the rules the three big US brands publish:
- Benjamin Moore says in the data sheet for its vinyl siding paint (Regal Select Exterior REVIVE, 2019): don't paint vinyl any color darker than the original or with an LRV below 55, unless the color is from the palette Benjamin Moore names for that paint and fits the siding maker's guidelines. Otherwise the siding may absorb more heat and warp. Separately, its Colors for Vinyl page describes a palette of 75+ colors for select exterior paint lines, and the brand says not to paint below 40°F.
- Sherwin-Williams sells VinylSafe colors: 100 colors with their own SWVS codes, including "a limited selection of darker colors formulated to resist warping or buckling", tinted in Emerald, Duration, SuperPaint and a few other lines. For any other color, the rule is no darker than the siding's original color.
- Behr says in its vinyl siding warp guide to avoid painting vinyl darker than its original color unless the paint or siding manufacturer recommends it.
Benjamin Moore also tells you to check the siding manufacturer's guidelines first. Check your warranty terms there too.
Below are colors from the Colors for Vinyl Siding list on Benjamin Moore's site. LRV is listed twice: the first number is the one Benjamin Moore publishes on each color's page, which is the one its 55 rule refers to. The second is calculated from the hex in Muro, and the two differ a little. For more on what LRV measures, see how LRV affects your paint choice.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV (BM site) | LRV (calc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Monterey White | HC-27 | #E9E5D0 | 75.33 | 77.9 |
| Benjamin Moore | Wickham Gray | HC-171 | #D4D8D2 | 67.87 | 67.8 |
| Benjamin Moore | Manchester Tan | HC-81 | #DBD2BC | 63.24 | 64.8 |
| Benjamin Moore | Stonington Gray | HC-170 | #CACBC5 | 59.36 | 59.3 |
| Benjamin Moore | Guilford Green | HC-116 | #CBCDAE | 57.22 | 59.4 |
| Benjamin Moore | Yarmouth Blue | HC-150 | #B5C8C9 | 55.82 | 55.3 |
| Benjamin Moore | Revere Pewter | HC-172 | #CBC6B8 | 55.05 | 56.5 |
| Benjamin Moore | Kennebunkport Green | HC-123 | #919D82 | 31.32 | 31.7 |
Kennebunkport Green in the last row is one of the deeper colors on the same list, along with Georgian Brick (HC-50, BM LRV 15.46). Both are far below LRV 55, so before you buy, ask a Benjamin Moore store whether the color is in the vinyl palette for the paint line you choose, and use it only if your siding maker allows it. And the "never darker" rule still applies: tan siding to Stonington Gray is fine, white to Revere Pewter is a step darker.
Combinations that work
| Your siding | Shutters | Front door | New wood trim |
|---|---|---|---|
| White, white trim | Tricorn Black SW 6258 | Caliente AF-290 | Extra White SW 7006 |
| Light gray, white trim | Hale Navy HC-154 | Hale Navy HC-154 | Extra White SW 7006 |
| Tan or clay, almond trim | Urbane Bronze SW 7048 | Tarrytown Green HC-134 | Alabaster SW 7008 |
| Cool gray, white trim | Iron Ore SW 7069 | Rainstorm SW 6230 | Extra White SW 7006 |
For more door ideas, see front door colors that work with your house.
How to check a color before you buy
- Hold the sample against the siding and the vinyl trim at the same time, not against the old door.
- Look at it in the morning, at noon and late in the afternoon. Gray siding can read blue in the morning shade and beige in evening sun.
- Step back to the street, where people actually see the house.
Before you buy sample pots, you can narrow the list in Muro. Take a photo of your house from the street, pick real paints by name or code, for example from the tables above, and see the door, shutters or siding in each color on your own house. In the iPhone app you can see it by day, at sunset and at night. You can also start in a browser at app.usemuro.com.
FAQ
What color front door goes with white vinyl siding?
Black, navy or red are the safest. Tricorn Black (SW 6258) is the classic, Naval (SW 6244) is a softer option, and Caliente by Benjamin Moore (AF-290) works if the shutters stay black or navy.
What color shutters go with gray vinyl siding?
A clearly deeper color than the siding: navy like Hale Navy (HC-154), a near-black like Iron Ore (SW 7069) or a dark teal like Rainstorm (SW 6230). If the shutters are vinyl, buy them in that color rather than painting them darker.
Can you paint vinyl siding a darker color?
Only with a color the paint maker formulates for it, such as a darker Sherwin-Williams VinylSafe color or a color from the vinyl palette Benjamin Moore names for its paint, and only if your siding maker allows it. Otherwise all three big brands say to stay at or lighter than the original color.
What LRV do you need to paint vinyl siding?
Benjamin Moore's rule is LRV 55 or higher, unless the color is from the palette it names for that paint. Stonington Gray (HC-170) at a published 59.36 and Manchester Tan (HC-81) at 63.24 clear it. Shaker Beige (HC-45) at 53.53 falls just below. It's on Benjamin Moore's Colors for Vinyl Siding list, but ask a Benjamin Moore store whether it's in the vinyl palette for your paint line.
What trim color goes with tan or almond vinyl siding?
A creamy white like Alabaster (SW 7008) for any new wood trim, so it matches the almond vinyl. For a stronger look, use bronze or deep green on the shutters and door, such as Urbane Bronze (SW 7048) or Tarrytown Green (HC-134).
