White House with Black Trim: Colors, Windows and Mistakes

The same two-story house with black window trim twice: crisp white siding on the left, warm creamy white siding on the right

For a white house with black trim, pick a clean white with only a slight warm undertone, such as Sherwin-Williams Pure White (SW 7005) or Alabaster (SW 7008), and pair it with a true black like Tricorn Black (SW 6258) or a softer charcoal like Iron Ore (SW 7069). Match the trim to the color of your window frames, not the other way round, and test both colors outside, next to the windows.

The look is simple. Three things decide it: the white, the black, and the windows you already have. Codes, hex values and LRV below come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. LRV is calculated from the hex value, not quoted from the manufacturer. A screen only approximates paint, and outdoors the sun makes every white look lighter, so a sample on your own siding has the final say.

Which white works for a house with black trim?

Black trim makes the white next to it look whiter. That is good news: you rarely need the starkest white in the fan deck. A white with a touch of warmth looks clean next to black and doesn't turn blue on a cloudy day. If you want the background on undertones first, read white paint undertones explained. More whites are in 12 best white paint colors.

Crisp whites: the sharpest contrast

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Extra White SW 7006 #EEEFEA 85.9
Sherwin-Williams Pure White SW 7005 #EDECE6 83.7
Benjamin Moore Decorator's White CC-20 #EBEDEA 84.2
Farrow & Ball All White 2005 #FBF8F4 94.2

These are the ones for modern farmhouse and new builds, for houses with a gray or black metal roof, and for lots of shade from trees.

Soft warm whites: the safe middle

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 #EDEAE0 82.2
Sherwin-Williams Greek Villa SW 7551 #F0ECE2 84.0
Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee OC-45 #EEECE1 83.6
Farrow & Ball Wimborne White 239 #F7F3E8 89.7

This middle group covers most houses and sits well with brick or stone accents, warm wood porches and doors, and south-facing fronts.

Creamy whites: an older, softer look

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Creamy SW 7012 #EFE8DB 81.2
Benjamin Moore Linen White 912 #F2EBDA 83.4
Farrow & Ball Pointing 2003 #F7F1E3 88.2

Creamy whites suit older homes, cottages, and houses with red brick or a brown roof. Next to black, cream reads clearly warm, so choose it only if you want that look. For brick specifically, see trim, door and shutter colors for a brick house.

Which black works for trim and windows?

Pure, inky black is rare in paint. Most "blacks" are very dark grays with a lean: warm, neutral, green or blue. On a house that lean shows up more than you'd expect, because the black sits next to a large white wall.

True blacks

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Tricorn Black SW 6258 #2F2F30 2.9
Sherwin-Williams Caviar SW 6990 #313031 3.0
Benjamin Moore Onyx 2133-10 #353434 3.5
Benjamin Moore Black Beauty 2128-10 #393736 3.9
Farrow & Ball Pitch Black 256 #3B3938 4.1

Use these on window sashes, front doors, shutters, and anything you want to read as black from the street. Door colors have their own guide in front door colors that work with your house.

Soft blacks and charcoals

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Sherwin-Williams Iron Ore SW 7069 #434341 5.6
Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze SW 7048 #54504A 8.1
Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron 2124-10 #494A4B 6.8
Behr Broadway PPU18-20 #434442 5.7
Farrow & Ball Railings 31 #45484B 6.4

The softer ones are for fascia, gutters, garage doors and porch posts, where a true black can look heavy. Railings has a blue lean, Urbane Bronze a warm brown one.

Five pairs that work

White Black Feel
Pure White SW 7005 Tricorn Black SW 6258 Classic, high contrast, the safe default
Extra White SW 7006 Caviar SW 6990 Sharp and modern
Alabaster SW 7008 Iron Ore SW 7069 Softer, a little warmer, forgiving in strong sun
Swiss Coffee OC-45 Wrought Iron 2124-10 Warm white, gentle charcoal
Greek Villa SW 7551 Urbane Bronze SW 7048 Warm and earthy, good with wood

One rule covers all five: keep both colors on the same side. A warm white wants a black that isn't blue. A crisp, cooler white can take a neutral or slightly blue one.

Start with the windows you already have

Most black windows are factory-finished vinyl, aluminum or fiberglass. You can't order their color by a paint code, so the frame is the fixed point. Hold your black paint samples right against the frame in daylight. If the frame looks slightly brown or slightly gray next to your sample, pick a black with the same lean, or choose a charcoal on purpose so the difference looks intended.

If you're thinking of painting vinyl siding, be careful with dark colors. Sherwin-Williams writes that on vinyl siding any color darker than the original shade can cause warping, and offers a limited set of darker VinylSafe colors "formulated to resist warping or buckling". That guidance is about siding, not window frames. Before you paint any frame, check the window maker's warranty.

What to avoid with a white house and black trim

  • A blue-white with a warm black. The white looks cold and the black looks brown. Keep the undertones on the same side.
  • Black on every edge. Fascia, gutters, downspouts, railings and window trim all in black can look busy. Pick the lines you want to draw, often windows and the front door, and let the rest blend into the white or a charcoal.
  • Choosing the white indoors. A white chip under kitchen lights looks warmer and darker than the same white in full sun. Look at samples outside at noon and late afternoon.
  • Ignoring the roof and stone. A brown roof or red brick pulls the whole house warm. A crisp white with a blue-black against it can clash.
  • The wrong sheen on trim. Flat black on trim and doors shows fingerprints more easily. Our paint finish guide explains why trim usually takes a higher sheen than siding.

How to check a color before you buy

Paint two large samples, at least 2 by 2 feet, on the sunniest wall and on the shadiest one. Put the black sample next to a real window frame. Look at them over two days, in the morning, at noon and around sunset.

To narrow the list before you buy samples, you can try the colors in Muro. You take a photo of your own house, pick real paints by name or code, for example from the tables above, and see the white on the siding and the black on the trim. In the iPhone app you can also see the house at day, at sunset and at night. In your browser, start at app.usemuro.com. Once the colors are settled, the paint calculator tells you how much to buy. If you're also thinking about resale, see which exterior colors tend to add value.

FAQ

What is the best white for a house with black trim?

A clean white with a slight warm undertone is the safest choice. Sherwin-Williams Pure White (SW 7005) and Alabaster (SW 7008) both look white next to black without turning blue in shade.

What is the best black paint for exterior trim?

For a true black, Sherwin-Williams Tricorn Black (SW 6258) or Benjamin Moore Onyx (2133-10). For a softer look on fascia and garage doors, Sherwin-Williams Iron Ore (SW 7069).

Should trim match black windows?

Usually yes, or be one step softer. Hold samples against the frame in daylight and choose a black with the same lean, or pick a charcoal such as Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron (2124-10) so the difference looks deliberate.

Is a white house with black trim still in style?

It's a long-running look tied to modern farmhouse homes. If you want it to feel less stark, soften both sides: Alabaster (SW 7008) with Iron Ore (SW 7069) instead of a bright white with pure black.

Can you paint vinyl siding or windows black?

Be careful. For vinyl siding, Sherwin-Williams says any color darker than the original shade can cause warping, unless you pick from its VinylSafe colors. For vinyl window frames, check the window maker's warranty first.

Should the front door be black too?

It can be, and it ties the look together. A door is also a safe place for a stronger color, as long as the trim around it stays black.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles