Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore: Price, Quality, Colors

The same living room twice: a warm greige wall in Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray on the left, a deep navy wall in Benjamin Moore Hale Navy on the right

Neither brand wins across the board. Benjamin Moore has the bigger fan deck and shows its prices online ($60.99 to $108.99 a gallon for its interior lines on November 16, 2026); Sherwin-Williams sells through its own stores, shows only a list-price range for the whole product line on the page and confirms the price after you sign in. Pick the color first: about 3 in 4 Sherwin-Williams colors in our sample have a very close Benjamin Moore twin, but only half of Benjamin Moore colors have one at Sherwin-Williams.

This is a comparison of what we can check: prices published by the manufacturers, their product lines, and color data. Codes and hex values come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. A hex value is only an approximation on screen, so a sample on your wall always has the final say. We didn't run our own durability or hide tests, so this post doesn't rank paint quality.

Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore at a glance

Sherwin-Williams Benjamin Moore
Colors, brand's own claim 1,700 3,500+
Colors with values in Muro 1,526 3,884
Where you buy 4,853 company-operated stores in the U.S., Canada and the Caribbean (end of 2025) Locally owned retailers
Price on the website List-price range for the product line; your price after sign-in Shown, per gallon
Code format SW plus four digits (SW 7029) Numbers and collection prefixes (912, 2133-10, HC-154, OC-45)

The color counts in Muro differ from the brands' marketing numbers because we count colors that come with a published color value, one entry per code. Treat both as rough sizes, not exact totals.

How much does a gallon cost?

Benjamin Moore lists a price for each product on its website. These were the 1-gallon prices on November 16, 2026:

Benjamin Moore line Sheen checked Price per gallon
ben Interior Eggshell $60.99
Regal Select Interior Eggshell $84.99
Advance Interior High Gloss $88.99
Aura Interior Eggshell $108.99

Retailers set their own final prices, so your local store can differ.

Sherwin-Williams shows only a list-price range for the whole product line on the page and confirms the price after you sign in. On the Emerald Interior page the range covered everything from small sizes to large containers, and the page asked us to "Register or sign in to confirm pricing & availability" on the same day. That range doesn't tell you what a gallon costs, so we don't quote one. Ask the store for the price of the exact line and sheen, and ask whether a sale is coming up.

Product lines: what each brand sells for walls

Both brands sell a ladder of interior lines at different prices. Their current interior lines, as listed on the brands' own sites:

For the same wall, compare like with like: the store's top line against the other store's top line, in the same sheen. If quality matters most, ask both stores for the product data sheets and compare the numbers each brand publishes, like recommended coats and coverage per gallon. Sheen changes how a color reads and how it cleans, so our paint finish guide is worth a look before you order. For what a whole room costs, see how much it costs to paint a room.

Colors: how often does one brand have the other's twin?

This is where most people actually get stuck: you love a color from one brand, and the other store is closer or cheaper.

How we measured it. We drew a random sample of 200 Sherwin-Williams colors and 200 Benjamin Moore colors from the manufacturers' color files in Muro's data. For each one we asked the Muro database, on November 16, 2026, for the closest color in the other brand, measured with CIEDE2000 (ΔE 2000). Below 1, most people can't see a difference; below 2, you'd notice it only with the chips side by side.

Two limits to keep in mind. 19 of the Benjamin Moore codes in the sample, OC and CC codes that are mostly whites and pale neutrals, didn't resolve in the database, so that side counts 181 colors and light colors are underrepresented. And the database holds 1,526 of the 1,700 colors Sherwin-Williams advertises, so the Benjamin Moore to Sherwin-Williams numbers may be slightly too low.

Closest twin in the other brand Sherwin-Williams color, twin at Benjamin Moore (200) Benjamin Moore color, twin at Sherwin-Williams (181)
ΔE below 1 (practically identical) 56 (28%) 22 (12%)
ΔE below 2 (very close) 156 (78%) 91 (50%)
ΔE below 3.5 (close) 195 (97.5%) 154 (85%)
Nothing within ΔE 6 0 5 (3%)

The result follows the size of the fan decks. With more than twice as many colors, Benjamin Moore usually has something very close to a Sherwin-Williams color. The reverse works only half the time. It's a sample, not the full catalog, so read it as a direction rather than an exact figure. For the bigger picture across 34 brands, see our study of 51,362 paint colors.

Color Code Hex Closest twin in the other brand ΔE
Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 #D1CBC1 Benjamin Moore Collingwood 859 0.85
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 #EDEAE0 Benjamin Moore Dune White 968 0.50
Sherwin-Williams Sea Salt SW 6204 #CDD2CA Benjamin Moore Gray Cashmere 2138-60 0.79
Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee OC-45 #EEECE1 Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 0.83
Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter HC-172 #CBC6B8 Sherwin-Williams Useful Gray SW 7050 1.10
Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 #D9D3C4 Sherwin-Williams Grecian Ivory SW 7541 1.66
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154 #434B56 Sherwin-Williams Charcoal Blue SW 2739 2.47

Agreeable Gray, Alabaster and Sea Salt switch brands almost invisibly. Hale Navy doesn't: its closest Sherwin-Williams color is visibly different side by side. If you want Agreeable Gray in detail, read our Agreeable Gray review. The closest rival of Agreeable Gray is covered in Repose Gray vs Agreeable Gray.

Which one should you choose?

  • You already have a color picked. Buy the brand of that color. If the other store is more convenient, check the twin's ΔE first. Below 1 is safe; above 2, put up both samples.
  • You haven't picked a color yet. Benjamin Moore has more colors to choose from. Sherwin-Williams has a smaller fan deck that is easier to get through.
  • You care about price. Benjamin Moore shows prices online, so you can compare lines at home. For Sherwin-Williams, sign in or ask the store for the exact line and sheen.
  • A painter is doing the job. Ask which brand they use and what they pay per gallon. Their price can differ from what's on the shelf.

What to avoid

  • Trusting the same name. Both brands sell a color called Alabaster: Sherwin-Williams SW 7008 and Benjamin Moore 876 are ΔE 1.78 apart, close but not identical. Always order by code, not by name.
  • Asking one store to "match" another brand's color by eye. Computer matching gets close, but it's a new formula in a different base. Ask for the closest color from their own fan deck instead, and compare samples. More on this in our post on matching paint colors across manufacturers.
  • Comparing prices across different sheens or lines. A top line in matte and an entry line in eggshell aren't the same product.
  • Buying five sample pots before you've narrowed the list.

How to check a color before you buy

Put up two samples, at least a foot square, on two walls of the room: one near the window, one in the darkest corner. Look at them in the morning, at midday and in the evening with lamps on.

To narrow the list first, you can use Muro. You take a photo of your room, pick real paints by name or code from either brand, and see them on your own walls side by side, for example Agreeable Gray next to Collingwood. In the iPhone app you can see the room by day, at sunset and at night. In your browser, start at app.usemuro.com. Once the color is settled, the paint calculator tells you how much to buy.

FAQ

Is Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore better?

Neither is better for every job. Benjamin Moore has more colors (3,500+ by its own count) and shows prices online; Sherwin-Williams sells through its own stores. Compare top line to top line, in the same sheen.

Is Benjamin Moore more expensive than Sherwin-Williams?

We can't say for sure, because Sherwin-Williams shows only a list-price range for the whole product line and confirms the price after sign-in. On November 16, 2026, Benjamin Moore listed $60.99 (ben) to $108.99 (Aura) per gallon of interior paint.

What is the Benjamin Moore equivalent of Agreeable Gray?

The closest in Muro is Benjamin Moore Collingwood (859), ΔE 0.85 from Agreeable Gray (SW 7029). That's practically identical on paper; check a sample on the wall.

What is the Sherwin-Williams equivalent of Hale Navy?

The closest is Sherwin-Williams Charcoal Blue (SW 2739), but at ΔE 2.47 it's visibly different side by side. Valspar Royal Navy (4011-4) is closer, at ΔE 0.64. More navies are in best navy blue paint colors.

Can Sherwin-Williams match a Benjamin Moore color?

The store can mix a computer match, but it's a new formula. Asking for the closest color from the Sherwin-Williams fan deck gives you a color with its own code that you can reorder.

Which brand has more colors?

Benjamin Moore. It advertises 3,500+ colors, Sherwin-Williams 1,700. In Muro we hold 3,884 Benjamin Moore colors and 1,526 Sherwin-Williams colors with published values.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles