Hale Navy (Benjamin Moore HC-154) is the lighter, grayer of the two, and it stays readable as blue in rooms without much light. Naval (Sherwin-Williams SW 6244) is darker and a little more saturated, so it looks richer in bright rooms and closer to black in dim ones. For walls in an average room and for most kitchen cabinets, pick Hale Navy; for a front door, an accent wall or cabinets in a sunny kitchen, Naval.
Codes, hex values and LRV below come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro, with the LRV each manufacturer publishes added next to it. A screen only approximates paint, and with navies the difference between these two shows up mostly in real light, so paint a sample before you buy gallons.
If you are still choosing between navies in general, start with our best navy blue paint colors. This post only compares these two.
Hale Navy and Naval side by side
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV (calc.) | LRV (manufacturer) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Hale Navy | HC-154 | #434B56 | 6.9 | 8.36 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Naval | SW 6244 | #2F3D4C | 4.5 | 4.458 |
The calculated LRV comes from the hex value. The manufacturers measure their own and get different numbers, Benjamin Moore especially. Either way the ranking doesn't change: Naval reflects noticeably less light than Hale Navy.
Naval also has a bit of history. Sherwin-Williams named it its 2020 Color of the Year, which is partly why you see it on so many cabinets and front doors.
What is the actual difference?
Look at the hex values. In Hale Navy the red, green and blue channels sit close together (67, 75, 86), which is what gray looks like in numbers. In Naval they are lower and further apart (47, 61, 76), so the color is darker and the blue has more of a say.
In a room that translates to three things:
- Hale Navy reads as a gray-blue. In daylight you see navy, at night it drifts toward charcoal. It gets along with almost any wood and with both warm and cool whites.
- Naval reads as a deep, inky blue. In good light it looks richer and more "dressed up" than Hale Navy. In a dim room after sunset it can pass for black.
- They are not twins. Side by side on the wall, you will see two different colors. If someone tells you to swap one for the other, test both first.
Which is better for walls?
For whole rooms, Hale Navy is the safer bet. Its calculated LRV is about half again as high (6.9 vs 4.5), so it gives back more light, and the gray in it keeps it calm when the light changes during the day. Bedrooms, studies, dining rooms and north-facing rooms all handle it well. If your room faces north, read paint colors for north-facing rooms first, because cool light flattens dark colors.
Naval works on walls when the room has good daylight, or when you want it to look dark on purpose: a library wall, a powder room, the wall behind a bed. In a small room with one window, a full Naval room will be cave-like by evening. Some people want exactly that. Just know it going in.
Keep walls flat, matte or eggshell. Both colors are dark enough that a shiny finish on a big wall shows every patch and roller line. The paint finish guide explains what each sheen does.
Which is better for kitchen cabinets?
Both are popular cabinet colors, and both look good. The choice depends on your kitchen's light and what sits next to the cabinets.
Pick Hale Navy if the kitchen doesn't get much sun, if the cabinets run along a long wall, or if you have warm wood floors and want the cabinets to look blue rather than black. It's also the easier match for white quartz with gray veining, because the gray in the paint picks up the gray in the stone.
Pick Naval for a bright kitchen, for an island in an otherwise white kitchen, or with brass or gold hardware. The deeper blue makes brass look warmer, and on an island the darkness reads as a deliberate contrast, not a gloomy room.
On cabinets, finish matters as much as color. Benjamin Moore sells its ADVANCE line specifically for cabinets, doors and trim, with a 16-hour recoat time on the label, so plan a weekend for two coats. More cabinet options are in best kitchen cabinet paint colors.
Which is better for doors?
On a front door, Naval is the stronger choice. Outdoor light is much brighter than indoor light, so its depth shows as color, not as black. It looks sharp against white, cream and light gray siding and on red brick. Hale Navy on a front door can look a bit muted next to light siding, though it fits well on a gray or greige house where you want the door to blend in rather than pop. For more combinations, see front door colors.
For interior doors, it depends on the hallway. In a narrow, dim hall, Hale Navy keeps the doors from looking like dark holes. In an open, bright space, Naval doors against white walls make a clean graphic contrast. Doors take a satin or semi-gloss finish, which also makes dark colors look slightly deeper than a matte sample.
Close matches in other brands
If your store sells another brand, these are the closest matches in Muro's data.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | ΔE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valspar | Royal Navy | 4011-4 | #414A55 | 0.64 to Hale Navy |
| Behr | Starless Night | PPU14-20 | #3E4855 | 1.54 to Hale Navy |
| Sherwin-Williams | Charcoal Blue | SW 2739 | #3D4450 | 2.47 to Hale Navy |
| Benjamin Moore | North Sea | CC-932 | #2B3B4C | 1.18 to Naval |
| Behr | Ink Black | N490-7 | #2F3E4A | 2.02 to Naval |
Muro labels a ΔE under 1 as practically identical. Between 2 and 3, the two colors are close, but you will usually see the difference when they sit next to each other. So the nearest Sherwin-Williams color to Hale Navy is Charcoal Blue, but it isn't an exact swap. If you want Naval and only have a Benjamin Moore store nearby, North Sea is close.
Which white goes with Hale Navy and Naval?
- Hale Navy works with warm and cool whites alike. Sherwin-Williams Alabaster (SW 7008) softens it; Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee (OC-45) does the same with a touch more cream.
- Naval looks best with a clean white that doesn't fight its blue. Sherwin-Williams Pure White (SW 7005) or Extra White (SW 7006) for trim and ceilings. A very yellow cream next to Naval can look dated.
What to avoid
- Treating them as interchangeable. Repainting a few Naval cabinet doors with Hale Navy, or the other way round, will show.
- Picking from a fan deck in the store. Store lighting is bright and cool. Both colors look bluer there than they will in your living room at 8 p.m.
- A tiny sample next to the old wall color. A dark sample on a white wall always looks darker than a fully painted room. Go big, at least 12 by 12 inches.
- Skipping the second coat. Plan for two coats on walls and cabinets, and ask the store whether they recommend a tinted primer for going this dark.
How to check a color before you buy
Paint Hale Navy and Naval next to each other on the actual wall, cabinet door or front door you are painting. Look in the morning, at noon and at night with your lamps on. With these two, the night view usually decides it.
To narrow it down first, you can try both in Muro. Take a photo of your own kitchen, hallway or front of the house, pick the paint by name or code (HC-154 or SW 6244), and see it on your own cabinets or walls. The iPhone app also shows the room by day, at sunset and at night, with lamps on or off, which is exactly where these two drift apart. In a browser, start at app.usemuro.com. Then use the paint calculator to see how many gallons you need.
FAQ
Is Hale Navy darker than Naval?
No. Naval is darker. Its calculated LRV is 4.5 against 6.9 for Hale Navy, and the manufacturers list 4.458 for Naval and 8.36 for Hale Navy.
What is the Benjamin Moore equivalent of Naval?
Benjamin Moore North Sea (CC-932) is the closest in Muro's data, ΔE 1.18 from Naval. Hale Navy is not an equivalent, it's lighter and grayer.
What is the Sherwin-Williams equivalent of Hale Navy?
The closest is Charcoal Blue (SW 2739), ΔE 2.47, close but visible side by side. Valspar Royal Navy (4011-4) is a much tighter match, ΔE 0.64.
Is Hale Navy or Naval better for kitchen cabinets?
Hale Navy for darker kitchens and long runs of cabinets, Naval for bright kitchens and islands, especially with brass hardware.
Does Naval look black?
In a dim room at night, it can. In daylight and on a front door it reads as a deep navy blue.
What color goes with Hale Navy cabinets?
Warm whites like Sherwin-Williams Alabaster (SW 7008) on the walls, white or gray-veined counters, and wood or brass details.
