Edgecomb Gray (HC-173) Review: Undertone, LRV, Rooms, Twins

The same living room with a linen sofa twice: light Edgecomb Gray walls on the left, deep Hale Navy walls on the right

Edgecomb Gray (HC-173) by Benjamin Moore is a light, warm greige: a soft gray with more beige in it than gray. Benjamin Moore lists its LRV as 63.09, so it stays light in most rooms and still reads as a color against white trim. It is one of the safer greiges for darker and north-facing rooms, and the main thing to watch is that it can drift toward plain beige in warm light.

Codes, hex values and LRV come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro, except where we link to Benjamin Moore's own figure. A hex value on your screen is an approximation, so a sample on your own wall gets the final word.

What color is Edgecomb Gray?

Brand Color Code Hex LRV
Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 #D9D3C4 63.09

Benjamin Moore publishes the 63.09 on its Edgecomb Gray color page. If you calculate it from the hex in Muro you get 65.3, a couple of points higher, so treat the manufacturer's number as the real one. Every other LRV in this post is calculated in Muro from the manufacturer's hex.

HC means it's part of the Historical Colors collection, the same family as its darker neighbor Revere Pewter (HC-172). The same page lists two Benjamin Moore colors with exactly the same RGB values: Alaskan Skies (972) and Baby Fawn (OC-15). If a store or a friend mentions one of those, it's the same color under another name and number.

What undertone does Edgecomb Gray have?

The hex breaks down to red 217, green 211, blue 196. Red is a little higher than green, and blue sits 15 points below green. That's a warm neutral with a touch of yellow, which is why it lands between gray and beige. In practice most people see a soft putty or mushroom color, not a gray.

Here is where it sits among the colors people usually compare it with:

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Pale Oak OC-20 #DDD9CE 69.5
Benjamin Moore Balboa Mist 1549 #DAD6CC 67.4
Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 #D9D3C4 65.3
Benjamin Moore Manchester Tan HC-81 #DBD2BC 64.8
Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 #D1CBC1 60.1
Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter HC-172 #CBC6B8 56.5

What does LRV 63 mean in a real room?

LRV goes from 0 (black) to 100 (white). Edgecomb Gray reflects a bit under two thirds of the light that hits it. That's light, but well below a white, which usually sits in the 80s.

In a bright room it looks pale, close to an off-white with a warm cast. In a dim room it settles into a soft greige and doesn't go muddy as fast as colors in the 50s do. Against white trim the contrast is visible but gentle, so doors and moldings stand out without a hard line.

That's why it gets picked for whole-house use: rooms facing different directions can all wear it without one looking heavy. More on reading the number in how LRV affects your paint choice.

Which rooms suit Edgecomb Gray?

North-facing rooms. Cool north light pulls warm colors toward gray, and Edgecomb Gray has enough warmth to stay soft instead of going cold. Our north-facing room guide puts it on the shortlist.

Open plans and hallways. It is light enough to carry from room to room, and it works next to both white and wood trim.

Kitchens with white or cream cabinets. White cabinets stand out softly against it. With cream cabinets, test a sample, because the two can blur together.

Bedrooms and basements. It feels calm under lamps at night, and in a basement with little daylight a light warm greige holds up better than a cool gray. See the basement paint colors guide.

South- and west-facing rooms are the one place to be careful. Strong warm afternoon light can turn it into plain beige. If you want gray to stay visible there, look at Pale Oak or Balboa Mist instead.

Which whites go with Edgecomb Gray?

Pick a white that is clearly lighter and only slightly warm. A very yellow white makes the pair look dated, and a very blue white makes Edgecomb Gray look dingy.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Simply White 2143-70 #F6F6ED 91.6
Benjamin Moore White Heron OC-57 #F0F1EA 87.4
Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee OC-45 #EEECE1 83.6
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 #EDEAE0 82.2

White Heron is on Benjamin Moore's coordinating list for Edgecomb Gray and is the cleanest trim choice here. Swiss Coffee is warmer if you want less contrast, and Alabaster is its Sherwin-Williams neighbor. Simply White is the brightest. More in the trim paint color guide.

Which darker colors go with Edgecomb Gray?

For a kitchen island, a front door, built-ins or one darker room, stay in the same muted, slightly warm family, or add a soft blue.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Pashmina AF-100 #BBB2A1 45
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165 #AAB2B0 43.5
Benjamin Moore Chelsea Gray HC-168 #86847C 23
Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal HC-166 #676662 13.3
Benjamin Moore Hale Navy HC-154 #434B56 6.9
Sherwin-Williams Iron Ore SW 7069 #434341 5.6

Pashmina and Boothbay Gray are both on Benjamin Moore's coordinating list for Edgecomb Gray. Pashmina is a deeper taupe from the same family, good for a dining room or an adjoining space. Boothbay Gray is a gray-blue that adds a little color without fighting the warmth. Chelsea Gray and Kendall Charcoal work on islands and lower cabinets. Hale Navy and Iron Ore give the strongest contrast and look good on a front door or a single dark room.

Edgecomb Gray twins in other brands

If your store doesn't carry Benjamin Moore, these are the closest matches in Muro's database. ΔE measures the visible difference: under 1 is practically identical, under 2 is very close.

Brand Color Code Hex ΔE
Vista Paint Harrow Gate C-229 #DCD5C6 0.72
Behr Stonewashed PPU8-15 #DCD6C6 0.80
Dunn-Edwards Heather DEC773 #D6CFBF 1.07
Valspar Warm Putty 6006-1A #DAD4C8 1.34
PPG Paints Cool Concrete 1023-2 #D9D0C1 1.60
Sherwin-Williams Grecian Ivory SW 7541 #D8CFBE 1.66

Behr Stonewashed is the easiest twin to find at a big-box store and is a hair lighter. Grecian Ivory is the closest Sherwin-Williams color, a little warmer and more beige. A twin matches the color, not the paint: sheen, coverage and how it touches up still differ. For touch-ups on a wall already painted in Edgecomb Gray, buy Benjamin Moore. The method behind these numbers is in paint color twins across brands.

What to avoid with Edgecomb Gray

  • Using it when you want a gray. In most light it reads as a warm greige or light beige. If gray is the point, look at Balboa Mist or Agreeable Gray.
  • Pairing it with creamy, yellow trim. The two warm colors run together and the walls look tired.
  • Strong west light without a test. Late sun can turn it into plain beige.
  • A cool, blue-leaning gray in the next room. Next to each other, both look wrong. Keep connected rooms in one temperature.

How to check a color before you buy

  1. Paint two large samples, one on the brightest wall and one in the darkest corner. Edgecomb Gray changes more with light than its pale look suggests.
  2. Check it in the morning, in the afternoon and at night with your lamps on. Warm bulbs push it toward beige.
  3. Put the sample next to your trim, floor and cabinets, not on a bare white wall. More in how to test paint colors before committing.

You can cut the list down before buying samples in Muro. Take a photo of your room, pick a real paint by name or code, say Edgecomb Gray HC-173 against Pale Oak OC-20, and see both on your own walls. The iPhone app shows the room by day, at sunset and at night, with lamps on or off. You can also start in the browser at app.usemuro.com.

When the color is settled, the paint calculator tells you how many gallons to buy.

FAQ

Is Edgecomb Gray gray or beige?

Somewhere in between, closer to beige than the name suggests. Its hex #D9D3C4 has clearly less blue than red and green, so most people see a warm greige or putty color.

What is the LRV of Edgecomb Gray?

Benjamin Moore lists Edgecomb Gray HC-173 at LRV 63.09. That's a light neutral, lighter than Agreeable Gray (SW 7029) at about 60 and Revere Pewter (HC-172) at 55.05, according to Benjamin Moore.

Is Edgecomb Gray lighter than Revere Pewter?

Yes, clearly. Edgecomb Gray sits at 63.09 and Revere Pewter at 55.05 by Benjamin Moore's numbers. Revere Pewter also leans a little more khaki.

Does Edgecomb Gray work in a north-facing room?

It's one of the better greiges for that. It has enough warmth that cool north light doesn't turn it cold, and at LRV 63 it doesn't go dark.

What colors go with Edgecomb Gray?

Benjamin Moore lists White Heron (OC-57), Pashmina (AF-100) and Boothbay Gray (HC-165) among its coordinating colors. For darker accents, Chelsea Gray (HC-168), Kendall Charcoal (HC-166) or Hale Navy (HC-154) work well.

What is the Sherwin-Williams equivalent of Edgecomb Gray?

The closest Sherwin-Williams color in Muro's database is Grecian Ivory (SW 7541), ΔE 1.66. The closest Behr color is Stonewashed (PPU8-15), ΔE 0.80.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles