On a white house, black, navy or a deep green shutter all work. On a gray house, look at the undertone first: cool gray takes black, navy or a dark blue-gray, warm gray takes bronze, brown-black or deep green. Red brick goes with black, navy or green, and a beige or tan house looks best with dark brown, deep green or oxblood.
Shutters are a small surface, but they sit right next to every window, so you see them from the street before you see much else. Codes, hex values and LRV below come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. LRV is computed from the hex. A screen only gets you close, so put a sample on an actual shutter before you buy a gallon.
The short version, by house color
| Your house | Example siding | Shutter colors that work |
|---|---|---|
| White | Sherwin-Williams Pure White SW 7005 | black, navy, deep green |
| Cool gray | Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray HC-170 | black, navy, dark blue-gray |
| Warm gray or greige | Sherwin-Williams Mindful Gray SW 7016 | bronze, brown-black, deep green |
| Red or orange brick | (the brick itself) | black, navy, deep green |
| Beige or tan | Benjamin Moore Manchester Tan HC-81 | dark brown, deep green, oxblood |
Two things decide most of this. First, contrast. A rough rule of thumb: siding with an LRV above 50 and a shutter under 10 reads clearly from the curb. If the gap is small, the shutters blur into the wall and the windows look smaller. Second, temperature: a cool siding wants a cool shutter, a warm siding a warm one. Black is the exception that gets away with almost anything. If LRV is new to you, there's a short explainer on LRV.
Shutter colors for a white house
White is the easiest house to pick shutters for, because it doesn't push any color away. The real choice is how formal you want it to look.
Black is the sharpest and most common. Navy is a little softer and feels coastal or colonial. Deep green looks older and calmer, and it's the one to try if there are big trees around the house. If you're going all-in on black, read white house with black trim first. It goes through which white to pair with which black.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Black Beauty | 2128-10 | #393736 | 3.9 |
| Behr | Totally Black | HDC-MD-04 | #3E3F41 | 5.0 |
| Sherwin-Williams | In the Navy | SW 9178 | #283849 | 3.8 |
| Behr | Starless Night | PPU14-20 | #3E4855 | 6.3 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Rookwood Shutter Green | SW 2809 | #303B39 | 4.1 |
| Benjamin Moore | Black Forest Green | HC-187 | #242E2C | 2.5 |
On a creamy white house, Black Beauty works better than a blue-black, since it has a hint of brown. On a crisp, cool white, In the Navy looks clean and doesn't turn purple the way some navies do next to bright white.
Shutter colors for a gray house
Gray houses are the tricky ones, because "gray" covers both blue-leaning and beige-leaning siding. Hold a sheet of white printer paper against the siding. If the gray looks bluish or green next to it, it's cool. If it looks a bit tan, it's warm.
Cool gray siding
Stay cool. Black is safe, navy looks sharp, and a dark blue-gray is the quiet option that still reads as a color.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Soot | 2129-20 | #373C41 | 4.4 |
| Benjamin Moore | Gentleman's Gray | 2062-20 | #304656 | 5.7 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Dark Night | SW 6237 | #23383F | 3.5 |
| Behr | Indigo Ink | HDC-CL-26A | #3B4354 | 5.6 |
Soot is a black with a little blue in it, so it doesn't look harsh against a light cool gray. Gentleman's Gray and Dark Night are blue-greens dark enough to read almost black on a cloudy day and clearly blue in sun.
Warm gray and greige siding
Here a cold blue or a pure black can look a little off, like it belongs to a different house. Go for a brown-black, a bronze or an olive-leaning green.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Black Fox | SW 7020 | #4F4842 | 6.7 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Roycroft Bronze Green | SW 2846 | #575449 | 8.8 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Andiron | SW 6174 | #424036 | 5.1 |
| Behr | River Forest | MQ6-54 | #545C47 | 10.0 |
Dark gray or charcoal siding
On a charcoal house, black shutters hardly show. You can paint them the same color as the siding or one step darker for a tone-on-tone look, or skip paint and go with stained wood. A light shutter on a dark house is possible, but it tends to look like the house was painted in reverse.
Shutter colors for a brick house
Brick has its own post with full tables: trim, door and shutter colors for a brick house. The short version: black works on nearly every brick, navy is the classic partner for red brick, and a dark, grayed green balances orange-red brick. On brown or tumbled brick, a brown-black or bronze beats true black. If you want a green that isn't in that post, Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Bottle Green (SW 2847, #324038) is deep enough to read almost black on red brick.
Shutter colors for a beige or tan house
Beige and tan are warm, so the shutter should be warm too, and darker than you think. A mid-tone brown on tan siding looks muddy because the two are too close. Go deep.
| Brand | Color | Code | Hex | LRV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Sealskin | SW 7675 | #48423C | 5.6 |
| Behr | Dark Truffle | PPU5-19 | #594D46 | 7.9 |
| Behr | Dark Everglade | HDC-CL-21A | #3D554F | 8.1 |
| Benjamin Moore | Tarrytown Green | HC-134 | #415752 | 8.5 |
| Sherwin-Williams | Rookwood Red | SW 2802 | #622F2D | 4.8 |
| Behr | January Garnet | HDC-CL-11 | #7A4041 | 8.2 |
Sealskin and Dark Truffle are the safe pick, especially under a brown roof. The greens give a tan house a bit more life. Oxblood like Rookwood Red suits older and farmhouse-style houses. On a cream or very pale beige house, January Garnet is brighter and reads as red, not brown.
Should shutters match the front door?
They can, and it's the easiest way to make the front look planned. If you want the door to stand out, keep the shutters the quieter of the two: black shutters with a red or green door, or navy shutters with a black door. Door colors by house color are in front door colors that work with your house.
Also look at the roof. A brown roof pulls toward brown-black, bronze and deep green. A black or charcoal roof is easy with black, navy and blue-gray.
Painting vinyl shutters a darker color
A lot of shutters are vinyl. Sherwin-Williams warns that a dark color over light vinyl can make it buckle. It sells VinylSafe colors, a palette of 100 colors formulated to resist warping on sound, stable vinyl. If your shutters are vinyl and you want to go a lot darker, pick from that list or check with the shutter maker. Wood and composite shutters don't have this limit. For the finish, satin or semi-gloss is the usual choice on shutters and doors; the paint finish guide explains the difference.
What to avoid with shutter colors
- A shutter only a shade darker than the siding. From the street it looks like you ran out of paint.
- Mixing temperatures. A cold blue-black on beige or a brown on blue-gray siding usually looks like leftover paint.
- Bright, saturated colors on the whole set. A bright red or kelly green shutter on every window gets loud fast. Keep the bright one for the door.
- Picking from a 2-inch chip. Outside, in full sun, a color looks lighter and brighter than on a chip in your kitchen. Navy can turn bright blue at noon.
- Ignoring the windows. If your window frames are white vinyl, black and navy shutters look crisp. With bronze or tan frames, warm shutters fit better.
How to check a color before you buy
Buy samples of your top two or three and paint a piece of board you can hold up next to a shutter. Look at the house from the street in the morning and late afternoon, because exterior colors shift a lot with the sun. Navy and green especially can read as black in shade.
You can also narrow the list down in Muro before buying samples. Take a photo of the front of your house, pick a real paint by name or code, for example from the tables above, and see it on your own facade. In the iPhone app you can look at it by day, at sunset and at night. You can also start in your browser at app.usemuro.com.
FAQ
What color shutters go with a white house?
Black, navy or deep green. Black like Benjamin Moore Black Beauty (2128-10) is the sharpest, navy like Sherwin-Williams In the Navy (SW 9178) is softer, and Rookwood Shutter Green (SW 2809) gives an older, calmer look.
What color shutters go with a gray house?
It depends on the gray. Cool gray siding takes black, navy or a dark blue-gray like Benjamin Moore Gentleman's Gray (2062-20). Warm gray and greige look better with a brown-black like Sherwin-Williams Black Fox (SW 7020) or an olive-green.
What color shutters go with a beige or tan house?
Dark, warm colors: brown like Sherwin-Williams Sealskin (SW 7675), deep green like Benjamin Moore Tarrytown Green (HC-134), or oxblood like Rookwood Red (SW 2802).
Are black shutters still in style?
Black shutters have been around on American houses for a long time, so they don't date the way a trendy color does. They work on white, cool gray, brick and most light houses. On a warm beige house, a brown-black often looks more natural than true black.
Can you paint vinyl shutters a dark color?
Yes, but use a paint made for it. Sherwin-Williams says a dark color over light vinyl can cause buckling and offers VinylSafe colors formulated for sound vinyl. If your shutters are already warped or loose, replace them instead.
