Kitchen Island Paint Colors That Work With White Cabinets

The same white kitchen twice: a navy blue island on the left and a sage green island on the right

With white cabinets, the island colors that work best are navy like Benjamin Moore Newburyport Blue (HC-155), a muted green like Sherwin-Williams Dried Thyme (SW 6186), and charcoal like Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal (HC-166). If you want a softer look, a light sage or a greige such as Saybrook Sage (HC-114) or Mega Greige (SW 7031) works too. Pick the island color by the undertone of your white: cool islands with crisp whites, warm ones with creamy whites.

Codes, hex values and LRV below come from the manufacturers' color data in Muro. The LRV is calculated from the hex value, so it can differ by a point or two from the number on the chip. A hex is also only an approximation on your screen. Paint a sample board and stand it next to your cabinets before you decide.

This guide is only about the island. If you are still picking the cabinet color itself, start with the best kitchen cabinet paint colors.

Start with the white you already have

"White cabinets" covers a lot of ground. A crisp white with a hint of gray and a creamy white with yellow in it pull the island in different directions. Hold a sheet of printer paper against a cabinet door. If the door looks yellow or beige next to it, you have a warm white. If it looks almost the same or slightly gray, it's a clean or cool white.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.) Leans
Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace 2121-70 #F4F6F1 91.5 clean
Sherwin-Williams Extra White SW 7006 #EEEFEA 85.9 clean, slightly cool
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 #EDEAE0 82.2 warm, creamy

Clean whites like Chantilly Lace and Extra White are easy with navy, blue-gray and charcoal. Alabaster and other creamy whites look better next to olive, sage, greige and warm charcoal. A cold blue-gray island next to a creamy white can make the cabinets look yellowed.

How much contrast do you want?

LRV tells you how much light a color reflects, from 0 for black to 100 for pure white. Your cabinets are somewhere around 82 to 92. The gap between that and the island decides how much the island stands out.

  • Island LRV around 35 to 50: a soft, tonal kitchen. The island reads as a different piece of furniture, but nothing jumps out.
  • Around 15 to 25: a clear two-tone look that still feels relaxed.
  • Under 10: a bold, graphic island. It anchors the room and hides scuffs, but it also shows dust and fingerprints on a matte finish.

In a narrow kitchen with one window, a mid-tone usually looks better than near-black.

Navy is the classic choice for an island with white cabinets. It looks like a color without fighting the white, and brass or gold hardware stands out on it. Blue-gray versions are calmer and good if you're not sure about blue.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Newburyport Blue HC-155 #465566 8.8
Benjamin Moore Van Deusen Blue HC-156 #485B6E 10
Sherwin-Williams Sea Serpent SW 7615 #3E4B54 6.7

Newburyport Blue is a medium-dark navy with a little gray in it, so it doesn't look loud. Van Deusen Blue is a touch lighter and bluer. Sea Serpent is darker and grayer, close to a blue charcoal, and good when you want navy that barely admits it. All three sit best next to clean whites. With Alabaster, pick Sea Serpent, since it has the least blue to clash with the cream. There's a longer comparison of navies and their undertones in best navy blue paint colors.

Green islands, from sage to olive

Green is the friendliest island color for warm whites. It goes with wood floors, butcher block and brass, and it doesn't feel as heavy as navy or black.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Saybrook Sage HC-114 #B1B7A2 45.8
Sherwin-Williams Evergreen Fog SW 9130 #95978A 30.4
Sherwin-Williams Dried Thyme SW 6186 #7B8070 20.8
Farrow & Ball Green Smoke 47 #737C70 19.2
Sherwin-Williams Rookwood Dark Green SW 2816 #565C4A 10.1

Saybrook Sage is light and gray-green, a gentle step away from white. Evergreen Fog is a gray-green in the middle range. Dried Thyme and Green Smoke are the two to test first if you want the island to read clearly green: Dried Thyme leans olive and warm, Green Smoke a little cooler and more blue-green. Rookwood Dark Green is a deep olive for a dark island next to creamy cabinets.

Charcoal and soft black islands

Charcoal looks modern and goes with almost any white. It's the safe bet if you have a busy countertop or patterned backsplash and don't want another color in the mix.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal HC-166 #676662 13.3
Sherwin-Williams Peppercorn SW 7674 #585858 9.8
Sherwin-Williams Cyberspace SW 7076 #44484D 6.4
Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron 2124-10 #494A4B 6.8

Kendall Charcoal is a warm, slightly brown gray, so it works with Alabaster as well as with crisp whites. Peppercorn is a neutral mid-dark gray. Cyberspace and Wrought Iron are soft blacks: Cyberspace has a faint blue cast, which suits clean whites and stainless appliances, and Wrought Iron is a neutral soft black.

Greige and taupe for a quiet two-tone

If navy or black feels like too much, a greige island gives you two tones without a strong contrast. It works well in open kitchens where the island faces the living room and you want it to feel like furniture.

Brand Color Code Hex LRV (calc.)
Benjamin Moore Pashmina AF-100 #BBB2A1 45
Sherwin-Williams Mega Greige SW 7031 #ADA295 36.9

Pashmina is a light, warm greige. Mega Greige is a bit deeper, with some gray to balance the beige. Both belong with warm whites. Next to a very clean white like Chantilly Lace they can look muddy, so test them there first.

Quick pairings

Cabinets Island What you get
Chantilly Lace (2121-70) Newburyport Blue (HC-155) Crisp, classic navy and white
Extra White (SW 7006) Cyberspace (SW 7076) Modern, high contrast
Extra White (SW 7006) Van Deusen Blue (HC-156) Brighter blue, coastal
Alabaster (SW 7008) Dried Thyme (SW 6186) Warm, cottage feel
Alabaster (SW 7008) Kendall Charcoal (HC-166) Warm and grounded
Alabaster (SW 7008) Mega Greige (SW 7031) Soft, tonal

What to avoid with a painted island

  • Ignoring the undertone of your white. A cool blue island against creamy cabinets is the most common mismatch.
  • An island color that's almost the cabinet color. A white island next to a slightly different white just looks like a paint mistake. Go clearly darker.
  • Picking the island before the countertop. The top covers the island, so test the paint against your actual stone or wood sample.
  • Wall paint on the island. It gets kicked by stools and wiped every day. Use a cabinet enamel in satin or semi-gloss; the paint finish guide explains the sheens.
  • A third strong color on the walls. With white cabinets and a navy or green island, keep the walls light and quiet. Our guide to the best paint colors for kitchens has wall options.

How to check a color before you buy

  1. Paint a large sample board, at least the size of a cabinet door, and lean it against the island at floor level.
  2. Look at it in the morning, in the evening and with the pendant lights on. Greens and charcoals warm up a lot under warm bulbs, and navy can turn almost black at night.
  3. Hold the countertop sample and a piece of hardware against it at the same time.

Muro won't repaint the island for you, since it paints walls, but the wall is the third color in this picture and the one people usually get wrong. Take a photo of your kitchen, pick a real paint by name or code, for example from the tables above, and see it on your own walls next to the white cabinets and the island. In the iPhone app you can check it by day, at sunset and at night, with the lamps on or off. You can also start in your browser at app.usemuro.com.

FAQ

What color should a kitchen island be with white cabinets?

Navy, muted green or charcoal are the most reliable choices. Benjamin Moore Newburyport Blue (HC-155) works with crisp whites, Sherwin-Williams Dried Thyme (SW 6186) with creamy whites, and Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal (HC-166) with both.

Should the kitchen island be darker than the cabinets?

Usually yes. A darker island hides scuffs from stools and feet and gives the kitchen a clear anchor. Aim for an LRV well below your cabinets, for example around 20 for Dried Thyme against about 82 for Alabaster.

What is the best green for a kitchen island?

For a light sage, Benjamin Moore Saybrook Sage (HC-114). For a clear mid-tone green, Sherwin-Williams Dried Thyme (SW 6186) or Farrow & Ball Green Smoke (47). For a deep olive, Sherwin-Williams Rookwood Dark Green (SW 2816).

Does a navy island go with Alabaster cabinets?

It can, but pick a grayer navy like Sherwin-Williams Sea Serpent (SW 7615). A bright, saturated blue can make a creamy white like Alabaster (SW 7008) look yellow.

Is a black kitchen island a good idea?

In a bright kitchen of decent size, yes. A soft black like Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron (2124-10) or Sherwin-Williams Cyberspace (SW 7076) is easier to live with than a pure black. In a small, dim kitchen, a charcoal such as Kendall Charcoal (HC-166) is the safer step.

MS

By Mariusz Szyma

Founder of Muro

I build Muro, the app that shows real paint colors on a photo of your own room. Before that I spent twelve years in product management, at startups and at larger companies.

Share this article

Related Articles